Instructive metaphors for teaching syntax
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21030/anyp.2020.4.3Keywords:
sentence structure, instructive metaphors, dependency grammar, constituency analysisAbstract
The paper gives an overview of instructive metaphors that may be adopted for the purpose of teaching syntax in the L1 classroom. In line with cognitive linguistics, it is assumed that the understanding of abstract target domains such as sentence structure has a metaphorical basis, crucially relying on the activation of more concrete source domains. The paper first discusses metaphors supporting a dependency grammatical conception of sentences. These include Tesnière’s view of the sentence as a theatrical performance and Brassai’s construal of sentences as feudal societies or solar systems. Finally, the paper also touches on the building block metaphor as a metaphorical basis for phrase structure grammars. It is suggested that for offering students a coherent picture of sentences, it is necessary to be mindful of the different metaphorical source domains and therefore (at least partially) incompatible assumptions associated with dependency- and constituency-based approaches.
References
Brassai Sámuel 2011 [1860]. A magyar mondat. I. értekezés. In: A magyar mondat. Tinta Könyvkiadó. Budapest. 10–98.
Brassai Sámuel 1873. Paraleipomena kai diorthoumena. A mit nem mondtak s a mit roszul mondtak
a commentatorok Virg. Aeneise II. könyvére. Magyar Tudományos Akadémia. Budapest.
É. Kiss Katalin 2006. Mondattan. In: Kiefer Ferenc (szerk.) Magyar nyelv. Akadémiai Kiadó. Budapest. 110–147.
Imrényi András 2017. Az elemi mondat viszonyhálózata. In: Tolcsvai Nagy Gábor (szerk.) Nyelvtan.
(A magyar nyelv kézikönyvtára 4.) Osiris. Budapest. 664–760.
Imrényi András 2019. Az állítmánytól a magmondatig. Acta Universitatis de Carolo Eszterházy Nominatae. Nova series tom. LXV. Sectio Linguistica Hungarica. 9–22.
Imrényi András, előkészületben. Versengő metaforák: a mondat forrástartományai.
Imrényi, András – Mazziotta, Nicolas (szerk.) 2020. Chapters of dependency grammar: a historical survey from Antiquity to Tesnière. John Benjamins. Amsterdam.
Keszler Borbála (szerk.) 2000. Magyar grammatika. Nemzeti Tankönyvkiadó. Budapest.
Kövecses Zoltán 2004. A metafora. Gyakorlati bevezetés a kognitív metaforaelméletbe. Typotex Kiadó. Budapest.
Lakoff, George – Johnson, Mark 1980. Metaphors we live by. University of Chicago Press. Chicago.
Langacker, Ronald W. 1987. Foundations of cognitive grammar 1. Theoretical prerequisites. Stanford University Press. Stanford.
Mayer, Richard E. 1993. The instructive metaphor: metaphoric aids to students’ understanding of science. In: Ortony, Andrew (ed.) Metaphor and thought. 2nd ed. Cambridge University Press. Cambridge. 561–578.
Medve Anna – Farkas Judit – Szabó Veronika 2010. 4x12 mondat. Gondolat Kiadó. Budapest.
Rácz Endre (szerk.) 1968. A mai magyar nyelv. Tankönyvkiadó. Budapest.
Tesnière, Lucien 2015 [1966]. Elements of structural syntax. Translated by Timothy Osborne and Sylvain Kahane. John Benjamins. Amsterdam.
(1) Éjszakánként földöntúli színekben pompázik a Jupiter jeges holdja. csillagaszat.hu. Csillagászati hírportál. https://www.csillagaszat.hu/hirek/ejszakankent-foldontuli-szinekben-pompazik-a-jupiter-jeges-holdja/ (2020. november 27.)
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2020 András Imrényi

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
The copyright of articles published in the journal belongs to the author. The journal has the right of first publication. The published work is licensed under Creative Commons License “Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International" (CC BY-NC 4.0). This means that copying, redistribution, remixing, transformation and building upon the published work is allowed for any purpose except commercial purposes as long as proper credit is given to the author, a link to the licence is provided, and any changes made to the original work are indicated.
The journal Anyanyelv-pedagógia [First Language Pedagogy] does not charge authors any fees for the processing, submission, or publication of articles. All writings published in the journal become freely accessible immediately after their publication.