Portrait and Subjectivity. A Thought Experiment after Béla Bacsó and Jean-Luc Nancy
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54310/Elpis.2025.2.7Keywords:
Mimesis, Representation, Methexis, Body–Soul Dualism, TouchAbstract
Following one of the central theoretical strands of Béla Bacsó’s Self-Face-Portrait. Aspects of the Portrait and bringing it into dialogue with Jean-Luc Nancy’s theory of portraiture, this essay examines the relation between portraiture and subjectivity. It takes the Renaissance portrait as its point of departure, approaching it not simply as a pictorial document of the emergence of the modern individual, but as a way of asking how an image can make a person present without reducing that person to likeness, identification, or the representation of character. The historical tension between exteriority and interiority, resemblance and evocation leads to the problem of the sacred image. The Byzantine controversy over images and the theology of the icon preserve a conception of the image in which presence and absence, resemblance and participation mutually condition one another. Rather than positing a direct historical continuity between sacred image and autonomous portrait, the essay explores the possible persistence of this relational structure. Following Nancy, the portrait can thus be understood not as the representation of an already constituted, self-identical subject, but as an event of subjectivity: an ex-position in which the self, moving outside itself and exposed to the other and to the viewer’s gaze, enters into relation with itself. The portrait does not overcome the absence of the sitter but gives perceptible form to that absence, in doing so, it renders subjectivity visible at the threshold between presence and absence, self-identity and alterity, and ultimately between life and death.

